The Bret Tobias Set “For Christ’s Sake” (2025)

Self Released
Buy:
Bandcamp

Hey! Is The Bret Tobias Set lining up to be a yearly Philadelphia Christmas tradition? Can I manifest this? We’ll see… (I missed 2024’s song… but go check it out!)

I wrote about The Bret Tobias Set’s excellent 2023 cover of Everything But the Girls’ “25th December” earlier this year, with what might be one of my shortest reviews of recent memory. I don’t know why I get sheepish about that kind of stuff – I just don’t want folks to think because I haven’t gone on and on about their record that I don’t really love it. Some days I just have a few minutes to spare, a headache, or existential ennui… you know… shit happens! Do all those words above count towards the review? I hope so!

The Bret Tobias Set is back with a reworking of a 2004 song that Bret wrote with his previous band, The Bigger Lovers, for their last record, This Affair Never Happened… And Here Are Eleven Songs About It. Bret calls the Lovers’ version “blue-eyed soul,” and I suppose I hear that – but it just sounds like a rock ballad to me. When I hear the term blue-eyed soul, I think about half the bands on Colemine Records, not The Bigger Lovers. But I am NO expert, despite this silly site.

Bret’s new version, which he calls a “country pop duet,” has Bret sharing vocals with Krista Umile, and man, these voices sound lovely together. The song lightens with the addition of Krista as well as the increased tempo, and as a result, the length shortens enough to leave you wanting more. I do hear the country twang, but I don’t know if I’d call this “country pop.” I would call it an “alt.country power pop ballad.” Gotta complicate things!

Bottom Line: This song’s arrangement feels like it has found its forever home.

LISTEN

High Tropics “All I Need This Christmas” (2023) and “Lonely Christmas” (2021)

Self Released
Buy:
Bandcamp

I have a tough time writing about songs you can’t actually go out and buy. A big part of why this site exists is not only to spread the best Christmas music I can find, but also to point you toward the best place to pay money for the hard work of these talented musicians. Art is work, and work deserves compensation. It really is that simple.

Because of that, I’ve been meaning to write about these two fantastic songs by Australia’s High Tropics for a while, but there’s never really been a place for you to purchase them—until today. I shot the band a note last night and, voilà: Bandcamp. So here we go.

I discovered High Tropics via the excellent Von Pip Musical Express podcast back in 2023 and was immediately smitten. Before diving into the songs, though, I have to address the elephant in the room: yes, these are the best Christmas songs the Strokes could ever wish to write. The similarity is undeniable, but that only serves to highlight the Strokes’ complete lack of original Christmas songs—and High Tropics’ absolute slam dunk in delivering two original seasonal gems.

2023’s “All I Need This Christmas” made my mix last year, thanks to its relaxed, synthy stroll through the well-worn “all I need for Christmas is you” territory. The lyrics are simple, essentially repeating the same verse twice, but even within that limited space, the song finds a way to feel fresh and new. Take the opening stanza:

Everybody’s talking ’bout a brand new year
I’m still playing catch-up with the last one, baby
I don’t wanna tell you how it ought to be
I’m just tryna make it to tomorrow lately

There’s something so laid-back and assured about this song—a calm, effortless cool that’s hard to deny. As the song puts it near the end, “I know I could win you over,” and it absolutely has.

“Lonely Christmas” first appeared on SoundCloud back in 2021, along with a demo version, and it’s only a matter of time before one of those makes its way onto one of my mixes. The lo-fi vocals, the sticky chorus, and—once again—that feeling of effortless cool the Strokes helped reintroduce to rock music in 2001 all come together beautifully here. High Tropics have kept that flame alive and turned it into something genuinely special.

The two songs feel like siblings, sharing a similar structure of repeated verses and a catchy chorus. Somehow, High Tropics manage to make yet another classic Christmas trope feel anything but stale.

Bottom Line: I can’t think of an A/AA single that would be quite as good as these two.

Wake Up and Smell the Sun – Icicle Miner Key Yuletide Trilogy (2025)

A puppet sits at a piano in a dimly lit room.

Self Released
Buy:
Bandcamp (NYOP)

What can one say about Wake Up and Smell the Sun, the music project of Philadelphia’s John Murray? That first review I wrote remains one of the longest and easiest I’ve ever crafted; I had never heard a Christmas record quite like it. Electric Snow knocked me on my ass — a lyrical and sonic mix that was unlike anything I’d encountered before. It felt like one of those videos where a blind kid puts on special glasses and sees for the first time.

So as I tackle this latest release, I come to it with the weight of those earlier impressions, as well as the thoughtful, self-deprecating, optimistic, and generous message John sent along with it. He presents the new release, Icicle Miner Key Yuletide Trilogy, in the context of his feelings about the holiday, the journey of these songs, and the creative energy of the Philadelphia music community that helped bring his vision to life. I’m fighting the urge to share his whole note, because it pulls you into the process in a way that only deepens your appreciation for the music. I connect with John’s work and his motivation in a way that cuts straight to the core — I’m always searching for songs I can love year-round, regardless of the season. That doesn’t mean I don’t care about the content; when someone can tap into something genuine, something human and rooted in the spirit of the season, there’s power in that. So when John writes, “First and foremost, Wake Up And Smell the Sun Christmas songs are songs. They are about Christmas, and all are conceived and birthed in the time and spirit of Christmas, whatever they end up sounding like,” I see the same relationship between craft and spirit that I’m constantly seeking.

Let’s dig into the songs. The first thing you’ll notice is that each track has its own distinct feel. John explains the sequence like this:

For this Trilogy, there are obviously three songs about Christmas. I chose the order too. The songs are stylistically very different. I intended for that to be a good thing. I imagine people being wholly perplexed by the ambitious power and synth-and-drum-driven proclamation of the first song, then making a strange turn into a contemplative indie rock feel for the second song, then finishing into a more traditional reel-to-reel torchlighting of the third song. A sonic quest. My quest for Christmas Music immortality.

I love that last bit — “my quest for Christmas Music immortality.” Every time someone hears a Christmas song they love and makes it a part of themselves, their holiday, their memories, they give that song a kind of immortality. Maybe the synths on “We Cannot Be Too Merry” will make you turn your stereo (go buy a stereo!) or headphones up as the ending washes over you: “We could be good / We could be good for you / We cannot be too merry / We cannot be too merry.”

Or maybe the chorus of “Jolly Good Time Indeed” will make you feel grateful for the warmth the season brings to your everyday life: “It’s a jolly good time indeed… for stories we still believe / and even if they don’t exist / it helps a little bit.”

And then there’s “Icicle Symphony,” whose finale might be the one that gets you. The emotion in the expanding orchestration — perfectly timed with the drums landing right as he sings, “Here come the holidays. Pry ’em wide open.”

John would be the first to tell you how much he owes to the people around him for helping make and share these songs. This record was once again recorded at Miner Street Recording in Philadelphia with Brian and Amy, and features Pat Berkery on drums, Robbie Bennett of The War on Drugs on synths, keys, and piano, and Matt Keppler on bass — his first appearance on a Wake Up and Smell the Sun project.

I don’t think John needs to worry about immortality. These songs — like the ones many of us have loved for years — stick with us. I’ll leave you with his wish for the season, which honestly could be a song itself:

Be well and try to be full of the Christmas spirit well after December. Not for votes, not for likes and follows, not for badges or rewards. Maybe do it for a girl, that would be ok. Or for a boy. That’s ok too. Do it for love, as so many songs say. Be full of the good spirits that spring forth from whatever holiday you celebrate. If you’re feeling triumphant, that is great, but be joyful too. And make some love and give it away. Anyone at all can do that.

Bottom Line: Fucking hell, I got emotional again. What kind of music blog is this? Go listen to some Christmas music, and maybe start with this record. Give it some everlasting life.

LISTEN

Pentire “Good Luck It’s Christmas” (2024)

Self Released
Buy:
Stream on Soundcloud

Pentire are a bunch of guys from a small town (Herefordshire, England) who “make pop songs for the post-jangle generation through the smiles and sweat of the mosh pit.” A fun turn of phrase indeed, which makes my next sentence sound bland as hell. Here’s a nice slice of indie pop/rock that, inexplicably, I can only find on Soundcloud. Enjoy my nearly flavorless introduction and press play. You’re likely to enjoy this one.

EDIT: Well I’ll be… it is a cover and I hadn’t realized it. This is a cover of Tellison, which can be found on their Bandcamp. And… I did have that song already and just plum forgot. Thanks Randy!

I swear I’ll get my Christmas music mojo flowing soon.

Bottom Line: Pentire are indeed Christmas music fans – keep an eye on them. They are who I discovered Devon from…

LISTEN

Shirese “Christmas in East Haven” (2024)

Grapefruit Records and C/Site Records
Buy:
Bandcamp

I have a recipe for you that you might like… let’s create a musical smoothie of a Christmas(?) song where you take the Velvet Underground, throw it in a blender with 90’s slacker stream-of-consciousness indie rock, and add a dash of…. melodica? Sounds like a high-dollar treat you could find in the trendier New York neighborhoods… or it could be “Christmas in East Haven” by the East Haven, Connecticut rock band Shirese. While I’m struggling to find the Christmas connection in this song (beyond the title), I’m totally grooving on this stepchild of “I’m Waiting for the Man,” as each listen has me bobbing my head a bit more. The chorus is an unexpected surge of energy, which really hooked me. I especially enjoyed the chorus when followed by the bridge… and all those weird little bleeps and bloops… just kinda refreshing, I suppose.

Bottom Line: It’s both 70s cool and 90s weird. Dig it.

LISTEN

UPCOMING: Jangle Bells – A Rough Trade Shops Christmas Selection (12/08/2023)

Rough Trade Shops
Buy:
Rough Trade (UK only so far)

Rough Trade Shops has a little Christmas gift lined up for their (so far) UK devotees… as they are releasing one of the strongest Christmas complications of the past few years. Compiling a number of top tracks from the recent past with a few exclusives, Rough Trade are flexing their taste muscles with this lineup. I’m most intrigued by the exclusives, obviously, and am paying particular attention to that Marika Hackman song, “Driving Under Stars,” as it sounds like a stripped-back version of one of my favorite holiday songs of the past ten years. The Peaness track, “Kiss Me Sweet Pea,” (edit – added below) could also be pretty amazing, as I really love this incredibly catchy band. There also appears to be a new Ellie Bleach track (edit – posted below!), which is encouraging… as I still may write about her previous song from a few years back (edit – she deleted it!) … Most certainly a worthy addition to your Christmas music collection, should you be the collector-type.

Tracklist (* denotes that I believe them to be exclusive to this release)

  1. Marika Hackman – Driving Under Stars (Piano)*
  2. Pale Waves – Last Christmas
  3. Allo Darlin’ – Will You Please Spend New Years With Me?
  4. Julia Jacklin – Baby Jesus Is Nobody’s Baby Now
  5. The School – Shouldn’t Be Alone For Christmas
  6. The Big Moon – It’s the Most Wonderful Time of the Year
  7. Los Bitchos – Los Chrismos
  8. Linda Lindas – Groovy Xmas
  9. Black Midi – Jingle Bell Rock
  10. Chubby and the Gang – Violent Night (A Christmas Tale)
  11. Peaness – Kiss Me Sweet Pea*
  12. Bubble and Squeak – The Christmas Stick
  13. Ellie Bleach – Merry Christmas, Do You Ever Think Of Me?*
  14. Sinkane – Christmas Wrapping
    CD Only
  15. Dream Nails – Lonely Star (Christmas Song)
  16. Willie J Healey – Merry Christmas
  17. Girl Ray – I Wish I Were Giving You a Gift
  18. Stars – Christmas Anyway
  19. Alex Lahey – Merry Christmas (I Don’t Wanna Fight Tonight)

Bottom Line: A good number of these tracks have been celebrated here before, so yeah, this looks good. Check it out, maybe buy the limited vinyl or the expanded CD… or cherrypick some songs below (where applicable) and give your money directly to the bands!

LISTEN

UPCOMING: Lenny Kaye, Cedar Sparks – Holiday Split 7″ (11/24/2023)

La Societe Expeditio
Buy:
Rough Trade

This upcoming release looks quite interesting and has the pedigree to be fantastic. Lenny Kaye, guitarist, founding member of the Patti Smith Group, and curator of the touchstone Nuggets compilation series, contributes a new song, “Santa’s Knee,” as well as scribbles his name on the cover of this Rough Trade-exclusive 7″ release. The B-side is the only known quantity from this slab of wax, as Lenny Shares the flip with Cedar Sparks, comprised of Tim Carbone (Railroad Earth) and Lou Rogai (Lewis and Clarke), as they share their 2018 folk-Christmas track, “Gathering Song.” Inspired by seasonal depression and “It’s a Wonderful Life,” “Gathering Song” is infused with beautiful, melancholy violin melodies and some wonderful sing-along lyrics. I can only vouch for 50% of this release, but so far so good.

EDIT: This is also an RSD Black Friday release. So… there are a few more than the 150 Rough Trade has. Whew!

Bottom Line: This looks like a very solid Christmas 7″ for the fan and the collector – Rough Trade is the exclusive retailer of 150 green vinyl signed copies. Grab them fast!

LISTEN

EDIT: Well… it appears that I may have hipped Cedar Sparks to the fact that their song was still available (for free) on Bandcamp. (And now it is gone)

The Walking Who “Halloween on Christmas” (2022)

Self Released
Buy:
Bandcamp

This song by Australia/Prague’s The Walking Who is equal parts epic and cryptic. Also… who the fuck cares what this song is about because “Halloween on Christmas” is fucking awesome. The song began its life in Australia back in 2019, but was only recently finished in November at a studio in Prague, with a strict palette of eastern European guitars, mics, and synths born between 1960-1985. Eastern bloc or bust! Pair this with those Toad Venom tracks and you’ve got yourself a pretty badass mix in the works…

Bottom Line: Let’s listen to psychedelic Christmas from the caves of Prague… what a great sentence to write, and what a fantastic song to jam to.

LISTEN

Dick Move “Eyes for Christmas” (2022)

Self Released
Buy:
Bandcamp (this has disappeared…)

Under the Radar, though not the Under the Radar you and I likely know and love, but the New Zealand online music mag has hipped me to this Christmas song that rips up the male gaze. Auckland, New Zealand’s lo-fi punks Dick Move bless my blog with perhaps the most aggressive song I’ve ever featured… as I am often on the chiller side of the musical dial. I’ll defer to their description of the song:

“This song is about a cracker of a one liner that echoes through small town Aotearoa. Someone staring, dare we say ogling at you? Hit ‘em with the almighty “you get eyes for Christmas mate?” And watch them shrivel. Simple, powerful, crack up stuff — and hopefully gone are the dayz of the male gaze.” – Lucy Suttor, Dick Move

Most certainly one of the more unique Christmas songs I’ve come across, and quite worth your time.

Bottom Line: Tear it up, Dick Move. We’re here for it.

LISTEN

Toad Venom – The Ingen vidare jul (Christmas is cancelled) EP (2021)

Welfare Sounds & Records
Buy:
Bandcamp

If I had a nickel for every time I said, “You name your band Toad Venom, and I’m going to check you out.” Well, a bunch of psych rock musicians from Vikingstad, Sweden finally took me up on this well-known offer, and have also made some absolutely excellent psych Christmas music! 2021’s The Ingen vidare jul (Christmas is cancelled) EP is two tracks of badass psych, as the leadoff track “God Jul” blasts off, a soaring Swedish Christmas anthem (to which I have no clue what is being said). The flip, “Merry (Christmas) and me,” is in English, and very much suits their style as described on Bandcamp: “A band, experimenting the void between spaghetti western and psychedelic rock.” Those twangy western guitars that introduce the track – so terribly cool. The song builds and builds, at times triggering me to think a bit about Spiritualized for some reason. There are so many cool movements to this song, yet it still comes in at an economical 4:00. Perhaps one of the most badass Christmas tunes I’ve come across in a good while.

Bottom Line: Two extremely good tracks from my new favorite band and best friends (pending).

LISTEN